Originally published on March 23, 2011
This is a joint movie review because their premises are basically the same: 80s male college graduate goes home after graduation pondering his future (played by Topher Grace and Jesse Eisenberg respectfully), gets a job beneath him to tide him over (Topher’s Matt: Suncoast Video, Jesse’s James: theme park worker), struggles to find himself, falls in love with a manic pixie dream girl of varying degrees (Teresa Palmer’s Tori, Kristen Stewart’s Em), and discovers fascinating things about himself.
The one glaring difference between the premise of each is that James in “Adventureland” needed the job to go to Columbia to get his Master’s. Matt in “Take Me Home Tonight” didn’t know what he was doing with his life. However, the storylines that propel them to the end are strikingly similar.
Actually, yeah, that’s all.
So what am I actually gonna comment on? The fact that these movies were made and marketed to appeal to omega males. I was going to reference Urban Dictionary but their definitions are all over the place.
Girls of similar ages and backgrounds go through the same things these boys are. Why hasn’t anyone done a movie like that for us females? God forbid we ask Hollywood to tell stories like that. If someone could do a movie like these as humorously as they did, and on the same level, I think it’d be a hit. But it’d have to be self-deprecating and wouldn’t wussy out like a romantic comedy. It has to be crass, unflinchingly honest, and real.
I think “Take Me Home Tonight” did a better job of drawing the viewer in with the premise than “Adventureland” did. “Adventureland” oozed pretentiousness, all darkly lit shots, and sharp dialogue; “Take Me Home Tonight” embraced the 80s, and had fun doing it.
I’m kinda iffy about the soundtrack for “Take Me Home Tonight.” It was supposed to take place in 1988, and a lot of the music seemed anachronistic. That’s the complaint I had for “Watchmen” too. “Safety Dance” was played during a hilarious scene. But “Safety Dance” came out in 1982. I don’t think I’d be bumping a song from ’82 in ’88. I have a hard enough time bumping a song from 2003 in 2010! No Michael Jackson or Madonna either. Two of the biggest artists we associate with the 80s and no appearance from either. On the other hand, “Adventureland’s” soundtrack nailed it. The cinematography made it feel too modern but the soundtrack helped keep it grounded in the late 80s.
What I will give both of the movies is that the boys were pursuing the girls show that the girls don’t have it together either. Teresa Palmer’s Tori loathes her full-time job; Kristen Stewart’s Em is all sorts of fucked-up. But that doesn’t let them off the hook. I think seeing the movie from the girls’ eyes would’ve made a fascinating story too.
Overall, I enjoyed both the movies for what they were. I couldn’t have imagined a better ending for either. They both met their natural end without taking away from the lessons we learned about each of the boys. Having been born in the 80s and grown up in the 90s, I’ve noticed that these self-discovery movies have a cycle. Every twenty years, someone makes a movie about their adolescence (high school/college), and it makes it more relatable. We’re still discovering how young adults function in the 2000s. So it’s easier to digest these personality issues when it’s placed in an era that we know through and through.
Ready to consume a creative writing podcast?
Subscribe to raconteuse radio!
This podcast examines how words on a page sound different when you hear the creator bring the words to life, while celebrating BIPOC emerging voices and the people behind the scenes too.
This weekly radio show will make you cry and gnash your teeth in 10 minutes or less… or your money back!